4 surprising truths behind the Broadway hit “Oh, Mary!”

Here’s what the Tony-nominated satire nailed about Lexington’s most misunderstood First Lady: Mary Todd Lincoln.

service-rbc-lprbscsm-scsm0424-001r.jpg

The life of Lexington’s Mary Todd Lincoln is the subject of the Tony-nominated satirical Broadway hit “Oh, Mary!” | Photo provided by Library of Congress

Cole Escola’s satirical Broadway hit “Oh, Mary!” reimagines the life of Lexington native Mary Todd Lincoln as she fantasizes about fleeing her life at the White House to chase her dreams as a cabaret dancer amid the Civil War.

Its hilarity earned “Oh, Mary!” five Tony nominations this year, including Best Play — but certain elements of the brazen by-gone biopic are actually rooted in historical facts about the misunderstood first lady.

Extravagant spending

When most Americans were financially struggling from the war, journalists reported heavily on the high costs of Mary Todd Lincoln’s wardrobe, her frequent New York shopping excursions, her trips to the shore, and her $20,000+ makeover of the White House.

Unpredictable moods

The play portrays Mary Todd Lincoln as having a “complex personality,” which aligns with historical accounts that describe her as having “mood swings” + “being prone to headaches.”

Nickname “Molly”

As his character does in the play, Abraham Lincoln often referred to his wife as “Molly.” Early correspondence between the two shows that he called her the nickname in some of their earliest love letters.

Insanity trial

Years after Lincoln’s assassination, the grieving widow was put on trial at the request of her son. A jury of 12 men ruled her insane + she was committed to a sanitarium in Illinois for three months while her son took over the family’s estate.

Two people standing and reading a sign outside of the Mary Todd Lincoln House.

The Mary Todd Lincoln House is presenting a four-panel traveling exhibit on the first lady that’s on display at the Lexington Senior Center through May 28. | Photo by Richie Wireman, courtesy of VisitLEX

Pro tip: If you can’t snag tickets to “Oh, Mary!” on Broadway, consider taking the self-guided Lincolns’ Lexington Walking Tour designed by curators at the Mary Todd Lincoln House.

More from LEXtoday
Independent Bookstore Day is your chance to turn the page on your next adventure while supporting local businesses and authors.
From who’s headlining to what their sound can be compared to.
The James Beard finalist is bringing her Sri Lankan-inspired cooking to national television while celebrating 10 years of Tuk Tuk Snack Shop with limited Saturday pop-ups in Lexington.
We dive into horse-related place names around Lexington.
The Lexington Public Library offers free educational resources that citizens can utilize to learn new skills, advance their careers, or just continue to stay curious.
Make the most of good weather by taking your meals al fresco on one of Lexington’s many beautiful patios.
Put your money where your community is and help us create a guide to small businesses by submitting your favorite local spots and sharing this page with a friend.
Talk about a work walk of art.
Discover and document local species as part of a worldwide effort to track biodiversity this spring.
Directly north, east, south, and west of us, cities across the world await.