Whenever we’re feeling saucy, we like to dig into a slice of local pizza. Lexington’s pizza scene is bubbling with options — and we keep finding ways to top ourselves. If you’re on the quest for the perfect slice, we’ve pie-oneered a list of 11 places to grab pizza that are definitely worth the dough.
Local legends
Goodfellas, Two locations
As a former New Yorker, City Editor Sam knows where to find the closest thing to a slice of New York pie. Head to the Distillery District for a sit-down, date night vibe or swing by its OG spot on 110 N. Mill St. to grab a to-go pie. You can never go wrong with a slice, a coke, and a breadstick (don’t forget the garlic butter.)
Puccini’s, Two locations
There’s something for everyone at this regional-local spot that offers everything from pizzas to make-your-own calzones.
Joe Bologna’s, 120 W. Maxwell St.
This year we bid a happy retirement to the man behind the breadsticks that Lexingtonians consider a rite of passage, but the restaurant which bears his name while continue on.Choose from round or Sicilian-style crust for a truly unique ex-pie-rience.
Think outside the pizza box
Pearl’s, 133 N. Limestone
Trendy and chic, this downtown treasure offers freshly made wood-fired pies — with an emphasis on seasonal, locally-grown ingredients. Plus, any pizza can be made completely plant-based.
Lexington-style
Rolling Oven, 725 National Ave.
Sometimes, you just have to pour a bag of Grippo’s over your pizza — or at least that’s how Rolling Oven rolls. Venture out to Mirror Twin Brewing Co. or catch its 20-ft shipping container food truck at various events around town.
PieTana, 210 Rosemont Garden
While you brainstorm what Lexington in a pizza would be, PieTana is busy making it a reality. Try out a beer cheese, hot brown-inspired, or Blue Door Smokehouse brisket-topped pizza.
Dingbats, 471 Jefferson St.
This newcomer started slinging ‘za in 2024 and quickly made a name for itself as a downtown destination for Roman style pies sold by the slice. Pro tip: try the Mystery sampler box with eight different slices curated by the crew at Dingbats.
If you can’t take the wheat
Smashing Tomato, Two locations
This fresh, casual spot from the Bella Notte Restaurant Group is a great quick lunch spot with 6" personal pies all under $10 — and can be made with fresh, gluten-free dough.
Pies & Pints, 401 W. Main St., Ste. 106
The best part about this spot is that any specialty pizza can be made with gluten-free or cauliflower crust. Think: exploratory toppings like street corn + tajin pie.
Old Chicago, 1924 Pavilion Way
We know this one is a chain, but we would be remiss to not include its countless gluten-friendly options. Order a Thai Pie with cauliflower crust pizza or get creative and build your own.
It’s delivery
Apollo Pizza, 1451 Leestown Rd.
Feed the whole family (and then some) with a 20" Wagon Wheel pie, with unique specialties like the Kentucky Hot Browne or the Appalachian Mountain.
Mad Mushroom, Two locations
Having a late night? Steamy, classic pizza and daily specials make for a college student’s dream.
Parlour Pizza, 2099 Harrodsburg Rd.
This regional chain is ready to satisfy wherever you are with options for carrying out, delivery, and dining in. In addition to pizza and pints, peep the signature cocktail menu for the perfect pairing.
What did we miss? Let us know if your favorite spot is missing and we’ll get it added.
